Ratings

My Rating System

How Worth the Credit rates LitRPG and progression-fantasy series. The tier scale, what each tier means, and why narrators get a separate one-to-five star scale instead.

Every series that comes through here faces its tribulation. Amazon hands out 4.7 stars to anything that shows up; the heavens send lightning. The tiers below are what survived, and where they landed when the smoke cleared.

Why tiers instead of stars

Star ratings break in a specific way for genre fiction. Amazon's averages cluster between 4.2 and 4.8. That range is supposed to span "okay" through "all-time genre flagship", and it doesn't. A novel that quietly delivers on every promise the genre makes and a novel that redefined what the genre could promise both land at 4.5 stars in the consensus, and a reader trying to choose between them learns nothing.

Worth the Credit uses a cultivation-tier system for series ratings instead. The names are borrowed from progression-fantasy's own vocabulary because the audience is fluent in them: tiers communicate categories of quality rather than fractional decimals. An A-mid series is a better recommendation than a 4.5-star average can be, because A-mid describes the kind of book it is rather than a number that compresses everything into 0.3 stars of meaningful difference.

The tier shown anywhere on this site is clickable. Land cold from a search result, see a tier you don't recognize yet, click through to this page — the rating explains itself.

The series tier scale

Twenty tiers, ordered from Mythic at the apex through F at the bottom. S, A, B, and C each split into four bands (peak → high → mid → low); Mythic, D, E, and F are single tiers used sparingly, Mythic most sparingly of all.

Mythic — the tier the book had to invent

Reserved for a series so far above the rest of the genre that calling it S-tier would understate it. You don't grade into Mythic; the book has to invent the tier. Membership is exactly one.

  • Mythic — Dungeon Crawler Carl (Matt Dinniman, narrated by Jeff Hays / Soundbooth Theater). The only series on Worth the Credit that sits above S, and the only series I believe ever will. The bar is did this series exceed what S was built to describe. Not a numeric score — Mythic is a category, not a measurement.

A series doesn't get a path into Mythic the way it has a path from B-peak to A-low. Mythic exists because Dungeon Crawler Carl forced the structural exception; if a second series ever earns it, the case will be made in writing on the series's review page rather than slid in by inference.

S — genre-defining

Reserved for the very top of the genre below Mythic. A series earns the S tier not by being excellent (several series are excellent) but by changing what readers expect from the genre, or by clearing a craft bar that puts it in conversation with the series that did. Four bands:

  • S-peak — the foundational classics. Cradle and He Who Fights with Monsters: not because they're the highest-rated on Amazon (they aren't always), but because the genre as a whole reset around what they proved was possible. The bar is did this series change the shape of LitRPG.
  • S-high — series that clearly belong in the S conversation but haven't (or haven't yet) bent the genre around themselves. The craft is at the flagship level; the cultural impact may catch up later, or may not. Examples: The Primal Hunter, Defiance of the Fall, The Licanius Trilogy.
  • S-mid — solidly S-tier. The series operates at a level that puts every component (character, system, prose, audio production) in the upper percentile of the genre, even if no single component is doing something the foundational classics didn't do first. Examples: Infinite Realm: Monsters and Legends, Beware of Chicken.
  • S-low — entry-level S. The series is good enough that demoting it to A-peak would understate it, but the case for S over A is the trajectory and the ambition rather than a finished argument. Examples: Warformed: Stormweaver (held at S-low by two specific craft decisions and a release cadence that keeps readers waiting), All the Skills, Last Life.

A series can be five-star excellent across every metric and not earn S. The wall between A-peak and S-low is a true bottleneck, the way cultivation stories mean it: most series meditate at that wall forever, and that is exactly how it should be. S is for the genre flagships and their close peers, and the breakthrough is deliberately rare so the tier means something.

A-tier — exceptional

The category for series that are clearly in the upper-quartile of the genre but haven't (yet) redefined the form. Four bands: the high subdivision exists so I can distinguish outstanding A-tier work that's pushing on the S boundary from outstanding A-tier work that simply sits at the top of the band:

  • A-peak — exceptional, almost S. The series sits one major breakthrough away from genre-defining status. Example: Battle Mage Farmer.
  • A-high — outstanding A-tier work that doesn't quite earn the "almost S" framing. The series is uncontested as upper-A, but the path to S isn't visible yet. Example: The Path of Ascension.
  • A-mid — excellent. Must-listen for anyone who likes the genre. Examples: Mark of the Fool, Welcome to the Multiverse.
  • A-low — very good. A clear recommendation, with honest caveats. Examples: Dawn of the Density God (upgraded from a provisional B-peak once I was current through Book 5), Overlord.

The internal differences across A-peak / A-high / A-mid / A-low are real but narrow. A reader who likes one A-tier series is statistically likely to enjoy others in the same band.

B-tier — solid

The category for series that earn their recommendations but ask something of the reader: patience with rough early books, tolerance for a specific niche, willingness to push past flaws. A B-tier series stays enjoyable through everything published so far. If I stopped reading it, it belongs in C. Four bands:

  • B-peak — approaching A territory. The series is good and would be A-tier without one or two specific issues. (No series currently sits at this exact band on the site.)
  • B-high — strong B-tier that doesn't quite cross into A. The reader gets a consistent payoff without the issues being completely absent. Example: Death Genesis.
  • B-mid — enjoyable, reliably good. The reader who wants what the series offers will be glad they tried it. Example: Terminate the Other World!.
  • B-low — worth it for the right reader. Often a niche pick; the recommendation comes with specific reader-fit guidance. Examples: Rise of the Winter Wolf, Jackal Among Snakes.

The B-tier is where most working LitRPG series land, and that's appropriate. Most books in any genre are good, not exceptional.

C-tier — mixed

The category for series with real problems, where the recommendation is conditional. I don't avoid C-tier ratings; a C-tier with specific caveats is more useful editorial than a soft B-tier that pretends the issues aren't there.

One structural rule governs the band: any series I stopped reading caps at C. A B-tier verdict promises the series stays enjoyable through what exists, and a series I quit buying is by definition one where that stopped being true. The sub-band records how good the run was before the stop. Disgardium earned eleven strong books before its bail and sits at C-peak, while a series that never justified its premise sits at C-low. For a series that fell off, the stop point is often the most useful thing a review can tell you, which is why C-tier is the home of the amber verdict badge explained below. Two boundary cases sit outside the rule: being current on an ongoing series is not a stop, and a series abandoned over outright quality collapse can fall below C on its own demerits.

Four bands:

  • C-peak — decent, with notable caveats. The series has real strengths, but the flaws are persistent enough that not every reader will get past them. Examples: Disgardium (eleven strong books before the arc that ended the run), The Ten Realms (S-tier through Realm 6, then the ending).
  • C-high — the strengths offset the flaws enough for a qualified recommendation, but the caveats still apply and the reader needs to come in with eyes open. Examples: The Bad Guys, Heretical Fishing.
  • C-mid — mixed. Situational. Borrow on Kindle Unlimited before spending a credit. Examples: Dungeon Lord, Reincarnation of the Death God.
  • C-low — hard to recommend broadly. Specific readers will find specific value; most won't. Examples: Starbreaker, Legend of the Dark Heart (stopped at 75% — strong opening that ran out of steam in Book 1).

C-tier ratings often come with the strongest editorial framing on the site, because why a series sits in this tier matters more than the number.

The amber badge: worth it, with caveats

Every review carries two labels. The tier says how good the series is. The verdict badge answers the question this site is named after: should you spend a credit on it? For a long time that badge had two answers, green Worth the Credit and red Not Worth the Credit, and almost every series fits cleanly into one of them.

C-tier didn't. It holds three very different kinds of series:

  1. Stopped after a strong run. Part of the series is worth the credit and part is not. The Ten Realms was S-tier through Realm 6 before the ending wrecked it.
  2. Strong for the right reader. The series does something well, but has a flaw I couldn't get past. A reader who doesn't share my hangup should buy it.
  3. Mediocre. Nothing drastically wrong, nothing that stands out. Not worth the credit.

Those deserve opposite advice, and a red badge on all three told anyone scanning the site that The Ten Realms and a series that never got going were the same skip. So the verdict badge gained a third state, Worth It, With Caveats, in amber. It never appears on its own; it always carries one of two qualifiers:

  • "Worth it: Books 1-7." The series has a clean place to stop. Buy up to that book, stop there, and you get the good part without the fall-off. Examples: The Ten Realms (through Book 7), Disgardium (through Book 11), The Bad Guys (through Book 6).
  • "Worth it, with caveats," with a one-line "worth it if" under the badge on the review page. The series suits a particular kind of reader, and the line tells you whether that's you. Examples: Red Rising (worth it if you don't share my hangup with how Darrow's story is handled), Ultimate Level One (worth it if you love long dungeon crawls and level grinding more than plot progress).

The third kind, the mediocre series, stays red.

How to read the three colors: green means buy it, red means skip it, amber means read why. The amber is deliberately a different color from everything around it. A C-peak with an amber badge is telling you something about that series is different from the C-peaks next to it, and the review explains what.

What amber does not change is the tier. The sub-band still records how good the series was at its best; the badge records how much of it is worth buying, or for whom. So far every amber badge on the site sits on a C-tier series, because C is where the honest answer to "should I buy this" is so often "some of it" or "it depends."

D, E and F: three different ways to miss

Everything below C carries the red Not Worth the Credit badge, so the badge already answers the buying question. The tier answers a different one: why it missed. Those are three different reasons, and they are worth keeping apart.

  • D — fell short. Something in the series didn't land for me, whether a protagonist I couldn't get behind, a book that never gets moving, or source material thinner than the adaptation everyone loves. Often competently made, and not a pan of anyone who enjoys it; it just isn't worth a credit to me. Examples: The Good Guys (a world worth caring about and a protagonist I could not stand), The Unintended Cultivator (well written, competently executed, no plot).
  • E — bad. The series fails at the craft level, or it is AI-generated slop. This is the tier for work I would not recommend to anyone. Example: Rise of the Devourer (an absurd premise it never recovers from, and the worst narration I have heard in a long time).
  • F — the regret tier. Series that actively angered me or made me regret the hours I put into them. F is not a measure of how badly a book is written; Super Powereds has exceptional prose and still sits here, because 150-plus hours with a protagonist who never became worth following is time I want back. Examples: Land of the Undying Lord, System Reborn, Super Powereds.

Most weak LitRPG still belongs in C with honest caveats. When a series lands below C, the review makes a specific argument for which of these three it is and why, rather than parking it at C-low.

Ratings on ongoing series

Every tier shown on this site reflects two things simultaneously: the quality of the series as it currently stands, and the point in the series I have personally reached. Both matter, and both can change.

The reading position matters. A rating on an ongoing series is based on how much of it has been listened to. If I'm through Book 6 of a twelve-book series, the rating reflects Books 1–6 — not a verdict on the whole. This is stated explicitly in reviews where the position meaningfully affects the interpretation (for example, a series where the arc is widely understood to shift in Book 8). Where a review doesn't specify otherwise, assume I was at the current publication point when the rating was assigned.

Ongoing series can rise or fall. A series in active publication can change. A run of exceptional books might push an A-high into S conversation. A widely anticipated entry that disappoints — the kind of book that arrives with expectation and then fails to deliver on it — can drag a tier down. The example on this site: Unbound by Nicoli Gonnella, which appears on the Series That Lost Their Way list specifically because the series was tracking toward a high tier before a book arrived that reset the conversation. Where a rating changes substantially after a new release, the review page will explain why.

Completed series hold their rating. Once a series is fully published and I've finished it, the tier is a permanent verdict on the complete work — including whether it sticks the landing. A series that ends badly may receive a retroactive downgrade; a series that builds to a conclusion better than its middle gets the same treatment in reverse. The final judgment on completed work is more authoritative than a mid-series position.

When in doubt: check the review for the series' publication date and the listening position. The tier is an honest opinion at a specific point in time, not a promise about what the next book will do.

Release cadence

Every ongoing series carries a release cadence grade. It answers one question: if you start this series today, how long will you wait for the next audiobook?

It grades the release schedule, not the author. The dates come from audiobook releases, and for a series whose narrator is in heavy demand the audio can trail a finished manuscript by months. Travis Baldree narrates eight series covered on this site, so some of what this number measures is his recording queue rather than anyone's writing speed. That is the honest thing to measure for an audiobook site, because the audio release is the thing you are actually waiting for, but it should not be read as a verdict on how fast someone writes.

Typical gap between audiobooks Grade
6 months or less 5.0
7 to 9 months 4.5
10 to 12 months 4.0
13 to 18 months 3.5
19 to 24 months 3.0
25 months or more 2.5
Abandoned 1.0

Completed series carry no cadence grade. The question the grade answers is how long you will wait for the next book, and once a series is finished there is nothing to wait for. A complete series gets a dash here, which is a better outcome than any score.

A book a year sits at 4.0 and is a perfectly good cadence. Releases measured in months rather than years are the exception and grade above it. The fastest cadences in the genre usually belong to series that were serialized on Royal Road before a publisher picked them up, so a large backlog was already written.

The number measures the recent pace, not the lifetime average. It is built from the last three gaps between audiobooks, and the time since the newest release counts as a pending gap once it is already longer than those. If you are three months into a wait on a series that normally ships every four, the grade still reflects four. If you are eighteen months in, it reflects eighteen, because that is the wait you are actually having.

That choice matters most on long series. The Good Guys averages a little over five months across sixteen books, which the bands would score 5.0, while its last three gaps are seven, fourteen and sixteen months. A lifetime average was rewarding history a new listener will never experience.

It moves in both directions on purpose. A series that speeds up climbs, and one that slows drops and then recovers. Shirtaloon lost close to a year to illness, so He Who Fights with Monsters reads lower here than its early pace deserves and will climb back as he returns to schedule. The grade is a description of right now, not a permanent mark against anybody.

Once a series has gone two years without new audio it stops being graded and becomes a hiatus. An ongoing label on a series with nothing released since 2024 is a claim the site cannot support, and a cadence score on it would be worse. The site rebuilds before every deploy and the open interval is recalculated from that day's date each time, so a series going quiet is caught on the next build rather than whenever somebody happens to look.

The grade is derived from the release dates in the review's own book list rather than assigned by feel, and prose-lint fails the build when a grade does not match. That rule exists because it drifted badly before it was written down: the twelve-month cohort alone had grades ranging from 3.0 to 4.5. It previously checked against a hand-typed expected-months field, which had itself drifted out of step with the real dates on seven reviews.

Narrator ratings — stars, not tiers

Audiobook narrators use a 1-to-5 star scale, with half-star increments. Separate system, different scale, deliberate choice.

The reason: narrator quality doesn't follow the same distribution as series quality. A narrator who does excellent work on every book deserves an excellent rating on every book, even if their work isn't redefining what audiobook narration can do, and a category called "genre-defining" makes less sense applied to performance than it does applied to authorship.

Three different questions, three different numbers

This tripped me up for a while, so it is worth being explicit. There are three narrator numbers on this site and they answer different things.

Where What it answers
narratorGrade, on a review How good is this performance, on this book?
Overall grade, on a narrator profile How good is this narrator across their body of work?
Comparative rank, on a narrator profile Where do they sit against everyone else in the genre?

The review grade is the one people misread. It is not a verdict on the narrator. Peter Kenny narrates The Witcher and twenty-three Iain M. Banks novels, and his work on Voidborne gets a 2.5, because the grade is measuring the recording in front of me rather than the reputation behind it. The same cuts the other way: a great narrator having an off day does not inherit a 5 from their back catalog.

That split is what keeps the comparative question out of the review. Jeff Hays is ranked first in the genre on this site, and that is settled on his profile, not re-argued every time he narrates something.

What the review grade means

Grade The performance
5 Is itself a reason to choose audio over print. It does something the page cannot.
4 Excellent and invisible. Characters stay distinct, nothing pulls you out of the book.
3 Competent. Clear, correct, unremarkable. Neither helps nor hurts.
2 A chore. Listenable, but the performance is working against your enjoyment.
1 Defeats the book. You lose words, rewind, or quit because of the audio.

Half-steps allowed, and used often.

The bar for a 5 is deliberately high, because a scale where every competent narrator scores 4.5 or better is no scale at all. That is precisely the failure this site complains about in The Amazon 4-Star Lie: the whole genre compressed into four tenths of a star, telling you nothing. A narrator grade that only ever ranges from 4 to 5 would be the same broken instrument.

So a 5 has to earn itself on the specific book. A narrator with limited vocal range who nonetheless carries a series cleanly is a 4 or 4.5, and that is a compliment, not a knock.