Cultivation
The Beginning After the End Review: Twelve Books, Zero Filler
The longest origin story in the genre, and it works
The Beginning After the End follows Arthur Leywin, who dies as King Grey of a semi-dystopian future Earth, a world where wars are settled by champion duels and he's the undefeated champion, and gets reincarnated into another world. As a baby. With his adult mind fully intact.
I need you to understand what that premise meant for me going in. I've complained about slow origins in half the reviews on this site, and this is structurally the slowest origin possible: TurtleMe barely time-skips, so you spend most of book one with Arthur as an infant crawling toward magic books, then more books as a small child, then an adolescent, and you don't really get Arthur as a man until somewhere around book seven. If someone had described that to me upfront, I'd have put the series off even longer than I did. And it's excellent. That's the review in one line: a writer talented enough to make a toddler protagonist compelling for several books, mostly by playing his adult knowledge of how magic should work against a world that hasn't figured it out yet, and by surrounding him with family, friends, teachers, and his father's old adventuring crew who all feel like real people who'd genuinely go out of their way for a friend's kid.
One more thing about the child arc, and it matters: it's handled with tact. There's an obvious creep hazard in an adult mind occupying a child's body, and TurtleMe is clearly aware of it as a writer; nothing in these books plays that situation for discomfort. If you want to see the exact same premise handled the other way, Jobless Reincarnation (Mushoku Tensei) runs the identical setup with a protagonist deliberately written as a lecherous old creep, inner monologue and all. I've only seen the anime, so no review of it here, but the comparison is the cleanest way I know to show how much craft TBATE's restraint takes.
Cultivation without the spreadsheet
Power here works like Cradle: no skill sheets, no level notifications, just core development, with core color marking the tiers. The LitRPG elements are minimal, which keeps the pages on plot, and the plot honors it. Dungeon runs teach you the world and the party instead of grinding for grinding's sake. Characters introduced in passing recur with weight. Wars have real costs, entire factions take losses that genuinely took me aback, and the villains do evil out of specific, comprehensible motivations, the ends justifying any means, rather than being born bad because the story needed a bad guy.
The regression arc that finally worked
If you read this site, you know I hate character regression arcs. TBATE contains the only one I can point to that's done so well it adds to the story. Late in the series, book nine or ten, Arthur takes wounds that devastate his core, and the book opens with him unable to cultivate at all. I was cringing in advance, because I could see the standard version coming: a wasted book on a scavenger hunt for the secret core-healing flower, or a gods' errand, or the discover-that-cores-were-holding-everyone-back-all-along twist. The genre has run those plays a thousand times. TurtleMe runs none of them. The situation resolves within a few chapters of Arthur waking, because the author treats it as an obstacle to the story rather than a substitute for one, and then the plot gets back to moving. That's the pattern across all thirteen audiobooks, honestly: I can't name a filler book. Even the big late-series training arc, Arthur learning among the dragon-adjacent faction, is really a relationship arc wearing training clothes, and it pays off in exactly those terms.
Practical listening notes
Two things worth knowing before you spend credits. First, the early audiobooks run short individually, so grab the publisher packs where they exist, two books per credit, which is also how I finally got into the series. Second, the fact box above says 13 audiobooks against a title that says twelve books; that's Podium splitting the twelve story volumes across thirteen audio releases, not a discrepancy.
Where it lands
S-mid, earned across every category: writing quality, cast depth, pacing discipline, and a premise executed so much better than it had any right to be. What keeps it from higher is the absence of the one transcendent, genre-defining thing, the same bar I hold everywhere, and the fact that for all its consistency it never quite produces a Malefic Viper or an Eithan to steal the show. What it produces instead is the most sustained, even quality of almost any long series I've covered, start to finish, zero filler.
Verdict
Worth the credit, and one of the better entry points to progression fantasy: light mechanics, high craft, Travis Baldree on narration duty. If the core-progression style is what hooks you, Cradle is the natural companion, with Beware of Chicken as the cozy cousin on the same power system. And if you've been avoiding TBATE because you heard about the baby thing, I did too, and we were both wrong.
Reading order
Books in publication order. Cover links go to Amazon, affiliate-tagged, so you get the book and I get a small cut.
Early Years
New Heights
Beckoning Fates
Horizon's Edge
Convergence
Transcendence
Divergence
Ascension
Among the Fallen
Reckoning
Retribution
Providence
Apotheosis
Early Years, New Heights, Beckoning Fates and Horizon's Edge: the date shown is when these volumes first became available to listen to, inside a publisher's pack. The store now lists them separately, dated October 1, 2024.
If you liked this, try…
- Cradle (Will Wight) — the most direct structural comparison: core-based cultivation with no system menus, a complete multi-book run, and the same discipline of working through character rather than stat display; if TBATE is your entry point to the genre, Cradle is the natural next read
- The Immortal Great Souls (Phil Tucker) — the other core-based progression fantasy on this site, and by my assessment Tucker's best work; if the cultivation framework appeals and you want to follow a single author across series, start here after TBATE
- Beware of Chicken (Casualfarmer) — shares the xianxia cultivation roots but couldn't be more different in register: slice-of-life comedy, a protagonist who wants nothing to do with the cultivator world, warmth over stakes; complementary rather than competitive
Content notes
Combat violence throughout, including large-scale warfare with significant casualties. Major character deaths. Brief content involving an adult consciousness in an infant's body, handled with consistent tact.
Frequently asked questions
Is the baby and childhood arc actually worth sitting through?
How LitRPG is this?
Does Arthur recover from losing his core without a ridiculous side quest?
What about the publisher packs — how do those work?
Is this a good first cultivation or progression fantasy series?
Read next
Worth the Credit verdicts (B-tier and above). Scroll the carousel for more.