System Apocalypse

Accidental Champion Review: A Poor Man's Defiance of the Fall

Reviewed Updated 3 min read

The verdict D
Not Worth the Credit Ongoing

A contrived start

I'll admit up front that I only got about eight hours into this book. I've seen that the series has some devout fans, and there are a lot of books in it. Maybe if I'd found it in my early days of LitRPG I'd have been more forgiving. To me, it felt like a poor man's Defiance of the Fall, though to be fair, I don't know which came first, and they only share some similarities.

The premise borders on stupid. The System arrives on Earth while Xavier Collins, a student who's a bit of a daydreamer and a gamer, is sitting in class, and through happenstance he gets offered the chance to become Earth's champion. He has no background that would qualify him for that at all. In his first trial, he's pitted against a soldier, a Marine type, and told to fight to the death. Neither of them knows what's going on. The soldier could just shoot him, but refuses to execute an unarmed civilian, so the System treats that as a forfeit and kills him, and Xavier wins the champion class by default. The System's reaction to the soldier refusing to kill a civilian actually checks out. The rest of it felt really contrived. Amusing as a premise, poor in execution. It started me on a "really, this is the best we can do?" vibe.

Why it works in Defiance and not here

You could say Defiance is just as contrived. Zac starts with crazy bonuses because he happens to be standing where a boss is supposed to spawn, they can't both spawn there, and they literally have a dice roll-off, which he wins. Later you learn his luck has been tampered with, which is part of why. But the author plays it tongue in cheek, borderline hilarious: it's absurd to everyone involved, Zac and the monster are basically standing there blinking at each other, and that makes it fun. Both setups are contrivances. Defiance's execution is fantastic, and this one's isn't.

Then the grind

From there it feels like an older LitRPG. It goes into the mechanics of the character sheet and what the stats do, which we all know by now. Then he starts encountering monsters and has to fight them to the death, and we get the classic morality breakdown over killing. I understand moral crises in a post-apocalyptic story where you're forced to kill people. A crisis over fighting monsters, after the System has just arrived, always strikes me as ridiculous. If a rabid animal attacks you, you defend yourself; you don't have a mental crisis over it.

After that, you're following him as he fights monsters, gets levels and skills, and figures things out. The writing is average. It's not poor, but it's not like Ashborn Primordial, where the writing is good enough to keep you interested through material you don't want to sit through. So watching him slog through mobs and grind levels just doesn't hold up. His class wasn't terribly interesting either. I know early classes in these series can't be, with limited abilities, but that's exactly why I wasn't willing to slog through the rest of the book hoping something would become worthwhile.

Nobody worth meeting

He barely interacts with anyone meaningfully, and when he does, the conversations are short and don't add new depth or intrigue. Eight hours isn't a lot of time to develop characters, I get that. But good writers can make a character capture your interest in a single scene with real humor or a really distinct trait. Here everyone felt generic, and the conversations were milquetoast. Even in Primal Hunter, there's more depth in the characters you meet in the first part of book one than I got from eight hours of this.

John Pirhalla

The narration is fine. In fairness to John Pirhalla, the story gave him very little to work with: most of what I heard was Xavier's monologue, inner and outer, and the few conversations he has, so there wasn't a supporting cast for him to show any range. He's better served in Level One God.

Verdict

Not worth the credit. D. It's not fundamentally bad. It's average Joe's pizza for a LitRPG: average writing, a rough start, and then nothing unique, fun or interesting enough to make me want to know more. Maybe I'm being harsh, and maybe I stopped a little early. The series clearly has an audience, there are a lot of books, and if this had been one of my first LitRPGs I might have enjoyed it a lot more. But there's nothing here that would make me pick it back up. If you want something similar, start with Defiance of the Fall.

Reading order

Books in publication order. Cover links go to Amazon, affiliate-tagged, so you get the book and I get a small cut.

If you liked this, try…

  • Defiance of the Fall (TheFirstDefier) — a similarly absurd lucky start, executed so well it's funny, and later explained; start there instead
  • Primal Hunter (Zogarth) — the same opening stretch of system arrival and first fights, with more character depth in its first part than I found in eight hours of this

Content notes

Monster combat and a death in the opening trial. Nothing graphic.

Frequently asked questions

What is Accidental Champion about?
The System integrates Earth while Xavier Collins is sitting in class. He picks Champion because he likes the sound of it, and gets teleported to the Tower of Champions to compete against people who have known about the System their whole lives.
Is it like Defiance of the Fall?
It shares some similarities: a system apocalypse and a regular guy who lands an outsized advantage through dumb luck. Defiance's version is absurd on purpose, funny, and explained later. Here, the setup just felt contrived.
Did you finish it?
No. I stopped about eight hours into book one.