LitRPG

Level One God Review: A Great Premise, a Broken Power Scale, and Bloody Steve

Reviewed Updated 5 min read

The verdict B-low
Worth the Credit Ongoing

Why I picked it up

Mostly because it was there. Book one was free with my Audible membership when I grabbed it, I'd seen a recommendation or two, and the premise got me curious. The gods of this world realize a threat is coming that they can't overcome, so the god the story follows gives up his memories and all of his power for a prestige class, a fresh start at level one with abilities no other class can get, even divine ones, in the long run. His bet is that if he rebuilds from nothing, they'll be able to beat what's coming. I think it was Dungeons & Dragons that introduced prestige classes, so that was cool to see used, and a god deciding to start over is a premise I haven't seen done very often.

Because the god used to be a human from Earth, a very long time ago, losing his memories of godhood leaves him with only the Earth ones. It's a way to work Earth knowledge, Earth perspective and some pop culture jokes into a world that doesn't reflect Earth at all. I've seen authors do this before, and it doesn't feel organic, but it's easily overlooked when the rest of the story carries the weight. Unfortunately, this book doesn't quite pull that off.

When it's good, it's good

The author's writing is good. It's the storytelling I don't care for, specifically the pacing. This is a book written on the assumption that you're going to keep reading, so it's comfortable letting the slow parts drag. When the pacing is tight it's really enjoyable, and when it drags, it really drags.

The best example is early on. He runs into a violent, goblin-like race that is fully prepared to kill and eat him, possibly in the other order, and he has a whole moral breakdown about whether it's right for him to kill them. I'd understand that if he were a modern man forced to kill other people to survive. These are hostile magical monsters trying to eat him. It feels forced, and more like page filling than anything else.

The flip side is that two of the self-contained adventures are great. Clearing out a village of cursed gnome-things, and the clan of bug people going into heat who want to have a giant insect orgy, are both tightly written, well paced, hilarious, and easily the high points of the book. Then you go to the sections in between and the author is putting a lot of detail into events that give very small gains and ultimately don't matter. You end up wondering why the last two hours couldn't have been more like those arcs.

The characters work

Where this book is strong is the people. The characters are good and complex, the banter lands, and the choices people make while following their own goals feel organic. The party dynamics work really well, and I even enjoyed the chapters from other characters' perspectives.

And then there's Bloody Steve. I've never seen a series do a misogynistic, racist, xenophobic gnome who is so overflowing with chad energy that a character who should be completely unlikable becomes possibly the best character in the book. He's so over the top that you start taking him seriously, and he never stops getting funnier. If you like the ridiculous, over-the-top streak in Dungeon Crawler Carl, Bloody Steve is that.

The ranks don't mean anything

Here's my biggest problem. The ranks make absolutely no sense. You have wood-rank characters, the entry rank, doing severe harm in the right situations to characters two ranks above them. Then you have iron rank, the next one up, where some characters seem almost unbeatable and others die in a single hit from another iron rank. Bloody Steve is supposed to be iron and routinely one-shots other irons and is nearly unkillable even to silvers. You get a silver who's supposedly as strong as a gold in one scene, beaten by another silver in the next.

The main character's abilities have the same problem. He gets a poison spray from his alchemy kit fairly early, and it basically kills anything it hits. Is it the tools, a rare reagent, something about a ranked item? The book never says, so it's just a murder hose. Meanwhile other things are utterly ineffective. Even the achievements and rewards don't add up. In some ways having the RPG elements hurts the story, because the numbers tell you what to expect and then the story ignores them whenever it needs to. It'd be better if the system were vaguer, or not there at all.

He only survives because he supposedly has instincts left over from being a god, which are never clearly explained. Without them, almost every situation beyond entry-level adventurer would have killed him. With them, he takes on a near-mythic, multidimensional being at the end of book one and comes out on top, while still sitting at level 44 of the 50 it takes to get out of the entry rank. So the fact that he's still a weak nobody doesn't really matter, and you'll feel the plot armor. Every time things shouldn't work out, he follows his instincts and they somehow do. If you need a story to set rules and then stick to them, you're going to have the same frustrations I did.

That's tied to the other disappointment. I picked this up figuring a god who sent himself back to the starting line would have enough advantages that I'd get to watch him become overpowered in a new way. The advantages he actually gets don't seem very good, the story has to work hard to make them matter, and it only manages it because the power scale bends to whatever the author needs. It's hard to believe a god would roll the dice on this setup.

Book two, maybe

The frustrating part is that book one ends in a good place. Everyone you've met is converging on the first major city, and the things you've been made curious about finally have real direction. It feels like book one was the first half of a book, and if the author had done twice as much in the same pages, or stripped out the in-between quests, this could have been a tight, strong story. So I may pick up book two if I hit a slow point in my queue. I think I'll have a strong reaction either way: if the pacing is fixed, I'll raise the grade and chalk this up to a rough start, and if it isn't, I'll drop the series fast.

John Pirhalla's narration is good, and I was pleased with the quality throughout. No complaints there. In fairness, this is the first time I'm aware of hearing him, and a new voice can earn a little extra credit just for being new, so his 4 may be a touch generous.

Verdict

Worth the credit, B-low, for the right listener. I finished it and I'm not sorry I listened. It's a mix of a slog with some really great parts, and at about fourteen hours it's on the short side, so the slow stretches don't go on forever. I don't think you'd be truly disappointed picking it up, and you'll find enjoyment in parts of it at a minimum. But if the hilarious, ridiculous side of it doesn't land for you, there may not be enough here to keep you going. I hoped for more from a premise this unique, and the author definitely has potential.

Reading order

Books in publication order. Cover links go to Amazon, affiliate-tagged, so you get the book and I get a small cut.

If you liked this, try…

  • Dungeon Crawler Carl (Matt Dinniman) — the over-the-top, ridiculous humor this book reaches for in its best arcs, done consistently instead of in bursts
  • Path of Ascension (C. Mantis) — the opposite approach to a power scale: ranks that mean something and a timeline that respects them
  • Jackal Among Snakes (Nemorosus) — another series that drops Earth memories into a lead whose new life does not obviously need them

Content notes

Combat violence against monsters and people. Crude humor, including a deliberately bigoted comic-relief character and an insect mating-season arc played for laughs.

Frequently asked questions

What is Level One God about?
This world has nine gods, and they know a threat is coming that they cannot beat. The god the story follows activates a hidden Prestige Mode: he gives up his godhood and his memories for a fresh start at level one with perks no other class gets, betting he can climb back stronger. He wakes up remembering only the life he had on Earth long before he was a god, which is how the series gets an Earth perspective into a world that isn't Earth.
Is it overpowered-protagonist fiction?
Not the way the premise suggests. I went in expecting a god rebuilding his overpoweredness in a new way. The advantages he actually gets are underwhelming, and he survives mostly on instincts left over from being a god, which the book never really defines.
Do the LitRPG mechanics hold together?
No, and for me that is the biggest problem. Ranks give you numbers to set your expectations by, and the fights ignore them constantly. If you need a story to set rules and stick to them, expect frustration.
Should I read book two?
I haven't decided. Book one ends with everything finally converging on the first major city, which is the most interesting the story has been. If book two fixes the pacing, the grade goes up. If it doesn't, I expect to drop the series quickly.