Progression Fantasy

Ashborn Primordial Review: Great Writing, Sixteen Hours of Origin Story

Reviewed Updated 5 min read

The verdict B-mid
Worth the Credit Ongoing

Why I finished it

Mixed feelings on this one. I tried book one because it was a free download and I'd heard mixed things about the series, and the only reason I got through it is that it's particularly well written. If the quality had been any lower, I'm sure I would have stopped. It just does a lot of things I don't like in a book, and does them at length.

Same old origin, very well told

Vir is the Ashborn Primordial. We don't know exactly what that is, but it's a being from the realm of ash that reincarnates every time it dies. This time it's been born into the human realm, in a low-magic backwater, so he's extremely weak and has none of his memories. Every so often one of his previous incarnations takes over, and those chapters give you a glimpse of what the endgame for this character will look like. They're very cool, and they're really the highlight of the book.

The rest is about as straightforward as it gets. Boy in the boonies, born sick for reasons nobody understands, the same origin as a dozen other leads. And of course the beautiful daughter of the town's most important family, the priest in this case, is his best friend for reasons that aren't really defined beyond the author needing a second lead. Maya isn't bad, to be clear. She has her own arcs and her own growth, and they're done well. It's that you'll have seen all of this many times before, with no twist on it.

Then, also of course, a corrupt royal in the capital puts a crusade-happy priest at the head of the holy order, who decrees that every Ashborn be rounded up and killed. Knights show up at the village. Vir tries to slip away with his father's help, they're caught, his father dies protecting him, and Vir survives only because the ghost of the forest, a reclusive master swordsman who turns out to be a knight in hiding, steps in. Maya's father reads between the lines, knows he and his wife will be executed, and helps them escape anyway. And the knight, to no one's surprise, is secretly a former general with a grudge against one particular royal. The story does nothing new. What keeps it going is that the writing is good enough to make familiar beats enjoyable.

The other thing I'd usually complain about is that Vir is 15 and 16 for most of the book, and teenage angst is not something I want in a story. Thankfully, it's not used at all. He behaves like an adult, for no reason other than the author wanting an adult's thought process at fifteen, but I'll take that over angst.

Arc two: the training montage

Book one is three arcs of about eight hours each. Arc one is Vir and Maya in the village, through the knights arriving and the escape. Arc three finally sends him out into the world. Arc two is a really long, boring training montage: the two of them living with this not-very-friendly knight, who is very clearly training them in assassination and infiltration.

This is the part where, if the writing had been any poorer, I'd have quit. I skipped chapters and listened to others at accelerated speed. You can't skip it entirely, though, or you'll be lost in arc three. A few characters are introduced in it, and the past-life takeover chapters are scattered through it.

The problem is how the time is spent. A 15 to 20 minute chapter will be the character training a skill or working out how something works, and maybe 5 to 10 percent of it matters to the plot or the characters. The magic system gets the same treatment, and it's an hour of going to school for something that's not particularly deep: people have affinities, mana is in the air and the ground, and the strength of your affinity is how much you can channel to power the orbs you cast with. Then in actual fights, better mages simply cast more, and worse mages run into mana problems when the story needs them to. None of the semantics you sat through change anything.

Since Vir is the one with the techniques, Maya is the one with the magic, and you get her progress in intricate detail. Did you need an hour of her failing to sense mana, then meditating to find it, then Vir describing how his techniques make him think about mana, which gives her an insight, which helps her channel it, which accelerates her progress, so she can finally start learning spells? It's just an utter slog of unimportant drivel. Vir's techniques follow a pattern too: the chapter where he gets the inspiration, the chapter where he fails repeatedly, the chapter where something unrelated gives him a deep insight, the chapter where it finally works, and the payoff five chapters later. You don't need four chapters to get to him using a technique. And for a story this slow, the chapters where the author flexes his prose on the texture of the grass and the scent in the air don't help.

Arc three, finally

In arc three Vir has real abilities and can venture out on his own, and you finally get the story you've been waiting for. He needs to join a mercenary order, and I thought, great, mercenary contracts, here we go. Then you get a chapter of him hunting rats in the sewers, and then they send him back to kill magic rats. It's a stupid fetch quest, except that he has two brief encounters with people who matter later, so you can't skip it either. Of that last eight hours, I'd say about four are relevant.

It reminds me of Mark of the Fool, which takes a very strong story and then lets it meander, because the lead doesn't have a pressing timeline pushing events forward. A lot of it is interesting and deepens the world, but you could skip it and miss nothing. As a general rule, if a third of your book is the student training with their master, I feel like you've failed as an author. Cut to fourteen hours, with the prose flexing trimmed and the dead plot points gone, this would have been a much, much stronger book.

Heath Miller

Heath Miller does a quite good job, and I do like his narration. I'd just finished the thirteenth book of He Who Fights with Monsters, so hearing a few of those characters' voices in here was a bit jarring. It doesn't diminish the quality of the narration.

Verdict

Worth the credit, B-mid, and book two decides it. As a book one, it's all in all a bad book one: sixteen hours of origin story and eight hours of him finally being good enough to go out into the world. But it sets up a larger story I have to admit I'm interested in, the high points are very cool, and the writing is a cut above what's usually seen in the space. Hard pressed, I land at mid B, because it gave me enough to want to see where this character goes.

If you don't share my issues with pacing and long origins, and you enjoy granular training, you'll probably like this a lot more than I did. If you're a Unintended Cultivator fan, this may be more in line with what you like.

I'm not picking up book two right away, though. Like Mark of the Fool, this goes on my list for a lull in the queue; Skill-Grinder book five and the newest Azarinth Healer come first. Book two will be a severe turning point. Now that the origin is done and he's away from his master, either it moves the plot along and the grade holds or improves, or it drops him into a new city to meander, and it becomes a C for being dropped. There are five books written, and I couldn't do five at book one's pace.

Reading order

Books in publication order. Cover links go to Amazon, affiliate-tagged, so you get the book and I get a small cut.

If you liked this, try…

  • Mark of the Fool (J.M. Clarke) — the same strong story losing its momentum because the lead has no pressing timeline; I enjoy both, slowly, and neither has made me want the next book immediately
  • The Unintended Cultivator (Eric Dontigney) — if granular training with little plot progression is what you're after, this is the closer match, and Ashborn at least gets moving in its third act
  • He Who Fights with Monsters (Shirtaloon) — the other Heath Miller series on this site, which is exactly why you may hear a few familiar voices

Content notes

A persecuted bloodline hunted by a religious order, a parent killed on screen, and assassination training. Violence throughout, nothing graphic by genre standards.

Frequently asked questions

What is Ashborn Primordial about?
Vir is a lumberjack's son in a remote, low-magic village, born sickly, with pale skin and blood-red eyes that mark him as Ashborn. He's also the latest incarnation of a being from the realm of ash called the Primordial, and he doesn't know it. When knights arrive with orders to round up and kill the Ashborn, he loses his home and has to find a kind of magic he can actually use.
Is the slow start worth pushing through?
For me, barely. The first two of book one's three arcs, about sixteen hours, are origin and training, and I skipped chapters and listened at one and a half speed to get through the second. The third arc finally sends him into the world and sets up a story I'm interested in. You can't skip the training arc outright, because important details are scattered through it.
Is it LitRPG?
No. There are techniques and a magic system based on affinities and drawing mana from the surroundings, but no levels or stat screens.
How is Heath Miller's narration?
Good, and he does a quite good job with this series. If you've just come off He Who Fights with Monsters, you'll hear a few of those characters in here, which was a bit jarring for me, but it doesn't diminish the quality of the narration.