Epic Fantasy
A Practical Guide to Evil Review: Villains Who Act Like Heroes, and a Lead Who Won't Stop Thinking
What I was promised
This came recommended as something different: a story that follows the villains, and was supposed to be more vicious and methodical than your typical hero story. I thought it was LitRPG going in. It distinctly isn't. There are no stats and no classes. What it has instead is an interesting system. The prologue is a cadre of villains talking to each other, the Black Knight, the Captain, the Squire, the Assassin, and it's confusing until you learn that Names are the power in this world. There are mages, fighters, orcs, goblins and the usual fantasy creatures, but as a person builds a story around themselves they can become a contender for a Name, there can only be one of each, and the Name grants the real power. There may be assassins in the world, but there's only one Assassin. Names are split between heroes and villains, and your powers both define your Name and are defined by its story.
The practical part works
The backdrop is a good one. The Black Knight is presented as the supreme villain: he led the Empire that conquered Callow, and he put a lot of people to the sword. But the Empire's goal was conquest, not annihilation. Once you've conquered a people, you need to occupy them so they generate tax revenue, and you can be ruthless in war but not to a populace, because if you're too ruthless they rebel, you put them down, they can't pay taxes, and you've damaged your own economy and stability. So the Black Knight rules by whatever is most practical for his goals. It mirrors a lot of real conquests, and the victor always makes himself the good guy.
That's the best of the book: how you govern occupied land, how much you intervene where there's wealth, how you handle areas with no natural resources that attract drifters and crime, and the twist of what seems morally good versus what's practically evil. There's also a neat idea in the Names themselves. Past Black Knights were undone by their Squires, usually after coercing them into the role, so this one has studied all of them and is trying to steer his own story away from their endings.
Catherine
The problem is the main character, and the book is told entirely from her point of view. Catherine is an orphan from occupied Callow with a penchant for underground pit fighting. Her plan was to save her fighting money to get into the Empire's war college, join the legions, grind up the officer track over twenty or thirty years, and, if everything went right, end up in charge of her home city with enough influence to make the occupation less brutal on her people. It's a good-guy goal, and it falls apart under scrutiny, but fine. Then the Black Knight, who hasn't taken a Squire in decades, shows up at a very convenient time and picks her. The book hand-waves the timing as fate pushing Named people together, and the only hint at why her is that he chose her precisely because she isn't special.
So she gets, overnight, more than her whole life plan was ever going to get her. She's out of the orphanage, treated like a noble, eating full meals instead of half rations, wearing armor he gave her, with the freedom to handle her own problems. And she spends the book begrudgingly going along with it, second-guessing him, being a general pain, and having a morality crisis over every hard choice. Some of those make sense. When farmers who helped a rebel faction would have been executed, and she gets them spared, her crisis felt real.
Then she needs a blood transfusion after a bad fight, the Black Knight requisitions six condemned criminals to be executed early so their blood can be used, and she goes on a whole morality tilt about how her old self could never have been okay with it. They were condemned criminals. She doesn't care that criminals get executed, and she isn't arguing they should go free. If they'd been random villagers, I'd understand. As it is, it's contrived, childish and petulant, and it isn't a sentence of doubt, it's pages of it. That's about where I turned the book off.
It wouldn't be so bad if this were occasional. But the book is lots of inner monologue before things happen and lots of inner monologue about her feelings after. Even in fights: both sides draw swords, and then you get five minutes of Catherine's internal strategy, her read on the opponent's strengths, and the lessons from earlier fights. The irony is that early on she's practical and clear-eyed about how hard her military path would be, how many awful things she'd have to do to her own people over a whole career to get any power to help them. Then she's handed a shortcut with much easier choices and balks at all of them. It's the inner ramblings of a whiny, petulant teenager who had a lot of ideas about who she'd be and folds like a cheap suit when confronted with reality. Maybe that's her growth arc, and the cast does start out young. I just didn't expect to be listening to an angsty teenager's inner monologue in a book called A Practical Guide to Evil.
Villains in name only
The rest of the cast is thin. The Black Knight gets the most depth because Catherine interacts with him most, and he still feels surface-level. He has some fun quips, and he's more anti-hero, or just a high-ranking general carrying out his emperor's will, than nefarious villain. The Captain, third in screen time, is two-dimensional. Everyone you meet comes with an exposition dump. And for a group of villains, they share camaraderie, friendship and mutual respect, they execute criminals, and otherwise they follow the law and don't use their status to bully the common folk. The book does make sure you know the Empire's rulers are ruthless in their history. But the villains you actually spend time with conduct themselves like a hero's party, and everything I heard was pretty black and white.
The action
The action scenes are the good part, because you finally get out of Catherine's head. The dialogue in them is good, there's some witty banter, and the fights are short and brutal. One I liked: she sneaks into a rebel faction and meets its captain, a decorated former knight, and after a couple of minutes of hearing what a big deal this woman is, Catherine kills her with a surprise attack. I didn't expect it, and that's what I liked about it. But there's no real power balance. In a critical fight against a hero who gets stronger when he's being heroic, she's clearly losing, then taps into her power right before dying and turns the whole thing around in a few moves. It's whatever the author needs, scene to scene. I'd have minded less if there were more action and less in between.
Verdict
Not worth the credit. C-low. I stopped with an hour and a half left in book one, after a long stretch of listening at one and a half speed and skipping thirty seconds at a time whenever Catherine started monologuing, because she goes on for minutes and most of what she bemoans doesn't matter, since she can't change it. It wasn't the worst thing I've listened to. The writing is fair, and Amber Dekkers's narration is perfectly good, nothing standout either way. Not every book is for everyone, and maybe I'm the wrong reader: I came in expecting something more adult and grimdark.
The only reason this is a C-low and not a D is that it clearly has an audience. The series has a strong fan base, the story is complete in writing, and maybe it gets better if you can get past book one. Book one just turned me off the whole thing, and I don't want to listen to Catherine complain anymore.
Reading order
Books in publication order. Cover links go to Amazon, affiliate-tagged, so you get the book and I get a small cut.
If you liked this, try…
Content notes
War, executions of condemned criminals, an occupied population, and a surprise killing. Violence is short and brutal rather than graphic.
Frequently asked questions
Is A Practical Guide to Evil LitRPG?
Is it actually dark or morally gray?
Did you finish book one?
Is the series finished?
Read next
Worth the Credit verdicts (B-tier and above). Scroll the carousel for more.