Isekai

How I, a Normal High School Student, Went to Royal Academy Review: A Fun Premise, Thrown Away

Reviewed Updated 4 min read

The verdict D
Not Worth the Credit Hiatus

Why I picked it up

Off the bat: this is one of the worst things I've listened to in a while, and I picked it up with pretty low expectations. I'd been on an anime binge with The Eminence in Shadow and Trapped in a Dating Sim, both about a main character who's secretly super powerful and trying to stay a background character. The title made me think this would be a fun little adventure in the same vein. A character steering an author's story behind the author's back is a ridiculous idea, but I appreciate a clever premise, and I was curious whether this could take something that silly and make it truly fun. It doesn't.

The opening is the best part

Samson is your regular high school kid who gets hit by truck-kun and dies. Death shows up, gives him a tour of the hells, and lets him know he's headed for one. His biggest regret in life? His favorite web novel, My Royal Academia, went on hiatus, and he never found out how it ended or why the author stopped. Death, it turns out, is also a big fan and was also really upset. So instead of hell, Samson gets a shot at redemption: go into the novel and direct the story, behind the scenes, so the author never takes it on hiatus. He picks a minor background character to inhabit, one who turns out to be good at everything he needs, and gets a quest system to tell him what to fix. And he has to do all of it without drawing attention, because if he becomes the main character, he fails and goes to hell.

It's such a ridiculous premise, and it all lands on you in the first chapter, that it's actually hilarious. I didn't mind the absolute bonkers absurdity at all. It hits you with everything up front, a shotgun blast of nonsense, and I just went along with it. The opening chapters amused me, and I liked that the author made that choice.

Then you meet the author

The problem is who Samson is up against. The author of My Royal Academia is utterly inept, and every quest is Samson correcting one of his blunders. The main hero is named Hero Goodlooking, named Hero because his family has high hopes for him, and Goodlooking because the whole family is known for it. That's a fun bit of wordplay. But Samson's very first job is to stop Hero from making a fool of himself in chapter one, because the author thought humiliating him would make him seem down to earth and approachable.

That's the whole book: a string of ridiculous, nonsensical moments where the author makes characters do stupid things for stupid reasons, and Samson quietly fixes them. There's no subtlety and no cleverness to it. The mistakes are so childish that it's impossible to believe the original story was ever popular enough for anyone to mourn its hiatus. So the premise doesn't just fail, it makes the story worse, and what Samson fixes it into is a very mediocre, straightforward academy story with nothing unique or interesting in it.

Between the quests, you also get the author's notes to his fans: him commenting on what's happening in the story, asking for feedback, and constantly being surprised by what his own characters did. I know some authors talk about characters becoming so real that they're hard to steer. But listening to this terrible author slowly get popular because someone inside the story is fixing his writing, while he marvels at how it turned out, is beyond contrived. If it had produced some incredible scenes, great dialogue, or an epic battle, maybe I could have gotten past that. It didn't.

J.S. Arquin

J.S. Arquin does his best, and he's a good narrator, but his range is very limited. I love The Path of Ascension, and it's very hard to listen to anything he reads without hearing Matt, Liz and Aster. Death here sounds exactly like Liz, same tone, same way of speaking and carrying herself, and it's hard not to just think of her as Liz. A lot of the cast reminded me of Path of Ascension characters, which is always a bit jarring.

Verdict

Not worth the credit. D. I had about an hour left in book one and decided I'd suffered through enough of it. I wasn't offended by it. The writing is fine: it's neither exceptionally good nor offensively bad, about average for what's out there in the space. It's the three-out-of-five-stars kind of book where nothing is done wrong and nothing stands out. But the concept seemed like it could be a lot of fun, the execution was terrible, and it just wasn't fun at all.

There are seven volumes out, so clearly there's a fan base for this, and I don't know Kal Griffith's other work, so I'm not calling him a bad author. I'm just not sure what you'd have to get out of this series to enjoy it, or how different your taste would have to be from mine. I can't think of anyone I'd recommend it to. For what it's worth, the series itself hasn't had a new book since 2024.

Reading order

Books in publication order. Cover links go to Amazon, affiliate-tagged, so you get the book and I get a small cut.

If you liked this, try…

  • The Eminence in Shadow (Daisuke Aizawa) — the stay-in-the-background premise that sent me looking for this one; the anime does it far better than either book
  • The Path of Ascension (C. Mantis) — the J.S. Arquin series I love, which is exactly why half this cast sounded like it to me

Content notes

A protagonist killed by a truck in the first chapter, and a tour of hell. Played for comedy. Nothing graphic.

Frequently asked questions

What is this series about?
Samson dies, and the grim reaper who comes for him, Aki, turns out to be a fellow fan of his favorite light novel, My Royal Academia, which went on hiatus before he could find out how it ended. Instead of going to hell, he's sent into the novel to steer the story away from the mistakes that will cause the hiatus, through a quest system, without ever becoming the main character himself.
Is it like The Eminence in Shadow or Trapped in a Dating Sim?
That's what I was hoping for: a super-capable guy trying to stay in the background. The premise is in that family, but the execution isn't fun the way those anime are.
Did you finish it?
No. I stopped with about an hour left in book one. I hadn't enjoyed it at any real point after the opening chapters.
Is the narration any good?
J.S. Arquin does his best with it, and he's a good narrator. His range is limited, though, and if you love The Path of Ascension like I do, a lot of these characters will sound like Matt, Liz and Aster.